Crochet hook test. Not what I was expecting!

I have been experimenting with a few different crochet hooks I have in my collection. It’s something I’ve wanted to do for a while.

Years ago now, I tested a heap of different crochet hooks. You can read all about that  here if you’re interested. That was more about hook comfort for me personally – about the feel and what I thought of how they worked.  My intention this time was to look at how things can change if you use a hook with a different pointy bit. Well that was the plan, but as you’ll see, it went off on a bit of an unexpected tangent!

After my hook test mentioned above, my go to hook has been the Knitpro Waves hook. I have them in a few different sizes, but the good old yellow-handled 5 mm is my most often used hook. It suits my style of holding the hook and we’ve become best friends. I’ve used it so much, changing to a different hook can take a bit of getting used to now.

I am quite often still adding to my hook collection though, and my most recent acquisition has a business end very different to most other hooks I have, so I got to wondering and then playing to see what a difference it would make to my crochet.

These are the 4 hooks I tested out. The matte silver one is my most recent addition. It came as part of an interchangeable hook set with a hand-turned wooden handle which was made by a local lady called Jo. It’s an inline style.

The lighter wooden one, is Brittany hook made of birch. It’s also inline. I’ve had it since the original hook test. It’s pretty!

The next one I picked up in Tassie earlier this year from ArtViva. So fun! It’s made from Tasmanian oak. It’s inline but with a slightly tapered tip.

The last one was my trusty Knitpro waves, which is a tapered style.

Here’s what they look like from the back…

And from the side….

All are classed as 5 mm hooks. The size of a crochet hook is determined by the diameter of the shaft. Going by eyes and feel, they all seem to have a similar shaft thickness to my eyes and fingers, except the matte silver one – that seems thicker.

I tried to use the knitting needle thickness gauge to check the diameter of all the hooks, but that didn’t work!

The Knitpro tip wouldn’t fit through the 5 mm hole. It splays out a bit at the tip. The Brittany, only the very tip fit through. The interchangeable – well no way was that going in the 5 mm hole. The only one that did and fit snugly in the 5 mm hole was the Artviva hook.

I can see the Knitpro shaft could be about 5 mm. See it poking through the 6 mm hole, there’s a bit of a gap? 1 mm-ish? The Brittany fit through the 5.5 mm hole, but again there’s a gap, could be about .5 mm making it also 5 mm? The interchangeable one though. – no way is that 5 mm.

The working part of the shaft fits snugly in the 6 mm hole and further down where you would work if doing really large stitches is 6.5 mm.

Hmm. I thought these were all the same size? Apparently not!
Because the knitting needle gauge tool wasn’t working enough to satisfy me, I borrowed hubby’s digital calipers to check the actual shaft sizes. Interesting results!

The Knitpro Waves is 5 mm around the shaft.
The ArtViva hook 5 mm around the shaft.
The Brittany hook is 5.30 mm around the shaft.
The matte silver interchangeable hook is 6.04 mm around the shaft.

At the pointy end, there was also big variation between the narrowest point of each hook, which you’d expect in tapered hooks.

The Knitpro Waves is 3.64 mm around the narrowest point.
The ArtViva hook 4.03 mm around the narrowest point.
The Brittany hook is 4.84 mm around the narrowest point.
The matte silver interchangeable hook is 4.85 mm around the narrowest point.

Once that was documented, even though the results showed the hooks are quite obviously not all 5 mm hooks, I tested each one using the first 5 rounds of Koro – a pattern from my Siren’s Atlas book. Pretty different results as you’d expect from my hook actual hook diameter measurements.

Going my all that, you’d think the square sizes would be from smallest to biggest , Knitpro Waves, Artvivia, Brittany and interchangeable. But no!

The difference in size between the largest and smallest was about an inch. That’s pretty significant for the supposedly same sized hook using the same yarn, but to be expected with the actual hook size. But, the middle two are in a different order to what I expected.

When I think about it, I think that is down to the cut out bit on the Brittany and Artiviva. If you look back up a the side view of the hook, you’ll see the Birttany one has a deeper notch. I did find with my crochet style, I had a harder time tensioning using the ArtViva one, and the yarn slid off the hook a bit. I am sure, with more use, my tension would improve using this hook. I am so used to my handled hook, working without one means I am not as consistent.

What I found interesting was working htr/hdc (UK/US) stitches. I find this stitch quite annoying to work as I find myself crochet-stuttering as I work them. I usually can’t pull through all three loops in one go. I usually go through 2 then one. It annoys me. It’s just a slight hiccup in the quick, smooth action I usually have. But with the inline style hook, no such stutter. It was smooth through all 3 loops.

So what does all that mean?

I started this with the intention of investigating inline vs tapered hook styles but ended up in a totally different place. I’ll try that again another day with hooks that are actually the same size hah.

So now I have done all this, what it all means depends on what you’re doing and if you absolutely must match the designer’s gauge/size. Unless you’re making garments, that’s not usually an issue with crochet. It’s just something to be mindful of. If you want to match size and gauge it will matter what kind of hook you use. If your hook of choice is not quite what it should be as some of these were, you could end up with a different result.

I guess you just need to remember that the hook you use may not actually be the size you think it is, but really, it won’t matter much or at all. A square is a square and a blanket is a blanket – size differences caused by it are pretty unimportant.

I had fun investigating, regardless! My crochet nerd brain is happy.

xx Shelley

8 Comments

  1. Kirsten Gittins

    Thanks Shelly. Moral of the story – don’t change hooks mid project ?

    Reply
    • Shelley Husband

      Oh my yes! Same hook for one project for sure 😉

      Reply
  2. Margaret-Rose Stringer

    Today it’s all changed (for me): I can reach the post and I can see the images in the email. Go figure.

    This is a terrific bit of research; but it seems it’s mostly for the benefit of those crocheting other people’s crochet patterns ! 🙂

    Reply
    • Shelley Husband

      Glad it’s worked for you today 🙂

      It was really done for my benefit – I was just interested in possible differences 🙂 Really doesn’t matter that much at all 🙂

      Reply
  3. Laura H.

    I have wondered about this as I have a set of interchangeable with a resin swirl handle that I bought at a local craft fair from a pen maker. It’s very comfortable to hold, but I have had the sense that the hooks are a bit larger than they are labeled. I may measure all of the whole set and make a reference chart for myself.

    Reply
    • Shelley Husband

      A good idea! I do love unique things and while they might not be exactly what we expect, there’s a joy in using them. Enjoy your special set 🙂

      Reply
  4. Sarah Payne

    Great research – I do love my Knitpro Waves

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.